Base Rate Fallacy

The base rate fallacy happens when people ignore general statistical information (the base rate) and focus only on specific details. This can lead to mistakes in probability judgments.

For example, imagine a town with 10,000 farmers and 10 librarians. Now, meet Emily, who is described as quiet, organized, and a lover of reading. When asked whether Emily is more likely to be a librarian or a farmer, many people might quickly say she's a librarian because her personality fits the stereotype of a librarian. However, this ignores the base rate - the actual number of farmers and librarians in the town.

Here's another example: Imagine only 10% of cases of food poisoning from milk come from consuming raw milk and 90% come from drinking pasteurized milk. Can we conclude that raw milk has a lower chance of causing food poisoning? No, not without considering the base rate. If only 1% of milk consumption is raw milk, we can conclude there is a much higher chance of contracting food poisoning from drinking raw milk.

By ignoring base rates in data analysis, we can make errors in judgment than can impact our ability to assess risk and make smart decisions. To make accurate assessments and predictions, we must consider both the specific details and the base rates.

Back to the Data Analysis Handbook